Up next in 10
Countries That ALMOST Existed
384 views
Mar 31, 2025
Support me on Patreon & get exclusive / ahead of time content! https://www.patreon.com/generalknowledge In this video I talk about a few countries that almost existed. With its creation being proposed but then not followed through for various reasons (save a couple exceptions where they were temporarily independent). On this list are states such as the Polish-Czechoslovak confederation, the Hellenic Republic of Pontus in Anatolia, Greater/Wilsonian Armenia, the Free State of Antwerp (where Flanders now is), a United Bengal (partially today's Bangladesh), the Fertile Crescent Plan - which proposed the unification of Iraq, Syria, Lebanon, Palestine and Jordan, Schleswig-Holstein, as well as three potential Central-American countries: Los Altos, Soconusco and Mosquitia / Miskito. TIMESTAMPS: 00:00 Intro 00:38 Polish-Czechslovak Confederation 01:24 Republic of Pontus 02:30 Wilsonian / Greater Armenia 03:39 Free State of Antwerp 04:58 United Bengal 06:08 Fertile Crescent Plan 07:07 Schleswig-Holstein 09:00 Los Altos, Soconusco and Miskito 11:50 Summary Support me on Patreon & get exclusive / ahead of time content! https://www.patreon.com/generalknowledge Follow me on Twitter: https://twitter.com/GKonYoutube
View Video Transcript
0:00
Countries that almost existed. On this channel, we talk a lot about countries
0:04
both the ones that exist now, the ones that did in the past, and sometimes also about ones that
0:10
almost existed. In this video, we're going to go through a few more of those. Now
0:14
most of these countries were proposed, but never truly created, for the reasons we'll learn ahead
0:19
while some others did exist for a short period of time, then being annexed or destroyed
0:25
and failing at their objective to remain an independent sovereign state. So let's jump straight into some of these almost countries, if you will
0:36
First, the Polish Czechoslovak Federation. The Polish Czechoslovak Confederation or Federation was a political concept from the time of World War II, supported by the Polish
0:47
government in exile. The UK and US weren't opposed to it, but never really sought to implement it
0:52
after the war, making their support seem circumstantial to the conflict. It was a revitalization
0:58
of the Miedzymor concept, proposing the creation of a federation based on Poland and Czechoslovakia
1:05
The Polish seemingly were all for it, but the Czechoslovak government in exile, not so much
1:10
After the war, the idea was definitively destroyed by the growing Soviet influence in Central and
1:16
Eastern Europe. It makes sense that they wouldn't want a strong independent federation that could
1:21
threaten their regional dominance. All the way in northern Anatolia, in what is today Turkey
1:28
there could have been a Republic of Pontus. After the end of World War I, the Ottoman Empire was
1:34
among the defeated central powers. They saw their empire collapse and be given to Britain and France
1:39
but they could have lost even more territory. This territory, previously the location of the
1:45
Roman Empire province of Pontus or the even more ancient Greek kingdom of Pontus is a region which
1:52
had a history of Hellenic culture, even after Persian and Turkish rule of Anatolia. American
1:58
President Woodrow Wilson had proclaimed that all the nationalities of the Turkish empire had a right
2:04
to their autonomy, and so the Pontic Greeks began calling for independence, with the issue being
2:10
discussed in the peace conferences. However, oddly enough, the opposition to this idea came from
2:15
Greece itself, stating that the new country would be too weak to withstand a Turkish invasion in the
2:21
future and too remote for them to support it. So, it was included instead in the larger proposed
2:27
state of Wilsonian Armenia. Let's move on to that other proposed country. Wilsonian Armenia
2:34
getting its name from the same President Woodrow Wilson of the US, refers to the
2:38
un-implemented boundary configuration of the First Republic of Armenia in the Treaty of
2:44
Sevres, a crazy treaty that completely destroyed Turkey by splitting its land among the Entente
2:50
powers and their allies, then never having been put into effect due to strong Turkish resistance
2:56
The proposed boundaries incorporated portions of the Ottoman regions which had Armenian
3:00
populations with an added inclusion of portions of the Trabzon Vilayet to provide an outlet
3:07
to the Black Sea at the port of Trabzon And like we saw some regions of the previously proposed Republic of Pontus were also added to safeguard these Greek people The United States ended up being the ones
3:19
who actually rejected the mandate for Armenia in 1920, and the idea was fully abandoned after the
3:25
Turkish War in the same year. The proposed political changes put forth by Woodrow Wilson
3:29
are really interesting. If you want, I can make a full video dedicated to that, kind of answering
3:34
a hypothetical question of what if Woodrow Wilson's plans had come to fruition
3:39
Back in Europe, we also have the Free State of Antwerp. The creation of this potential
3:44
country was connected to the Flaaout Partition Plan for Belgium. At this time, Belgium was
3:49
still ruled by the Netherlands, although its people began demanding independence. However
3:54
major European powers were divided on whether or not to support these claims and kept stalling
3:59
the negotiations at the 1830 London Conference. The French, for one, would have preferred
4:05
to annex the French-speaking provinces in Wallonia, but everyone else didn't want
4:09
him to do so. So, French diplomat Charles-Maurice de Talleyrand proposed an alternative which
4:16
according to them, was more reasonable. France would take the provinces of East Flanders
4:20
Einout, the south of Brabant, and the west of Namur. The north of Brabant would go to
4:26
the Netherlands, Prussia would take all territory east of the Mills River, and then Antwerp
4:31
Ghent, and the rest of West Flanders would become an independent, free state. But still
4:37
this proposal was not seen as good enough by other great powers who decided to grant all of Belgium
4:43
independence as one political entity. It's very interesting that up to today, there's a big
4:49
debate on whether or not Belgium should split up into two countries, Flanders and Wallonia
4:54
it's interesting that as early on as this, it was already an issue
4:59
Moving to Asia, we have United Bengal. United Bengal was a proposal to transform the Bengal province of the British Raj into an undivided sovereign state
5:08
at the time of the partition of India in 1947. All of the region was controlled by the British and upon independence
5:15
it became first a part of India and Pakistan and then India and Bangladesh
5:19
Their goal was, according to them, to prevent the division of Bengal on religious grounds
5:24
which I guess was what ended up happening. The proposed name for this country was the Free State of Bengal
5:31
There was some historical reasoning to this. There had been a Sultanate of Bengal that controlled these regions from 1332 to 1576
5:39
and apparently there was a regional administration of the British that had under its control the area that the new country claimed as their own
5:46
Within the British government, there was serious consideration of the proposal due to their desire
5:51
of safeguarding commercial interests there. India was, however, only in support of it if they became
5:56
a part of the Indian Union. The proposal was never put to a vote and ended up not happening
6:01
Although I guess Bangladesh today is a version of it, it just doesn't include all the areas
6:06
they initially idealized. For the West and the Middle East, there was also the Fertile Crescent
6:12
The Fertile Crescent Plan was an Iraqi proposal for the union of the Kingdom of Iraq with
6:17
mandatory Syria which at the time included mandatory Lebanon mandatory Palestine and Transjordan It was based on the fact that the ruling monarchies of all these regions were of the same Hashemite dynasty Nouri al Prime Minister of Iraq at the time presented the plan to the British during
6:36
World War II when it appeared that France had become too weak to hold on to Syria due
6:41
to its collapse in Europe. Northern Syrians were in support but some others weren't due to the heavy British influence
6:47
within the Iraqi government. didn't want to stop being a French protectorate just to become a British one. The two Ashamite
6:54
kingdoms briefly created the Arab Federation in 1958, joining Jordan and Iraq, but it and any hope
7:01
for the Fertile Crescent Plan ended with the overthrow of the Iraqi monarchy in 1958
7:07
All the way in Europe, Schleswig-Ulstein. The Schleswig-Ulstein question was a diplomatic
7:12
issue around the 19th century, although issues regarding it continue to come up later on in
7:18
history, Schleswig was a Danish Duchy, while Olstein was just on the other side of the
7:23
Danish border, being in medieval times a thief of the Holy Roman Empire
7:27
From 1460 onwards however, the two had been ruled together by a common duke, who in practice
7:33
was also the king of Denmark. But the joining of these two states was soon to be put in question
7:38
The German confederation, formed in 1815, then included Olstein, and by the early 19th
7:44
century, Osteyn's population was, along with much of Schleswig, almost entirely ethnically
7:50
German. In 1848, Frederick VII of Denmark announced to the people of Schleswig the promulgation
7:56
of a liberal constitution, under which the duchy, while preserving its local autonomy
8:02
would permanently become an integral part of Denmark. This led to an uprising by Schleswig-Osteyn's
8:08
large German majority in support of independence and close association with the German confederations
8:14
An uprising that was in fact supported by the Prussian military and initially they were
8:19
able to drive Denmark's troops away from the territory beginning the First Schleswig War
8:25
The Danish ended up winning this one, but then there was a second Schleswig War in 1864 which
8:30
led to the Dutchies and corporations within Germany. Should have Prussia won that first war, perhaps independence would have been granted
8:37
It's arguable if the state would have joined a united Germany later on, but a path for
8:42
lasting independence would have been created. It would be odd to have this extra country in between
8:47
Denmark and Germany today. Speaking of modern times, following the defeat of Germany in World
8:52
War I, Northern Schleswig was finally reunified with Denmark after two referendums. A small minority
8:58
of ethnic Germans still lives there as well. All the way in America for a change we have Los Altos
9:04
Sokonusko and Moschitia, three countries that could have existed in Central America. Moschitia
9:10
or Miskito was on the coast of Nicaragua today, while Los Altos and Soconusco were both in what
9:16
is today northern Guatemala and southern Mexico. Soconusco was a part of the general captaincy
9:21
of Guatemala, a Spanish colony, from 1609 to 1821. After the Spanish left, it belonged to the
9:27
Federal Republic of Central America for a couple of months, but then accepted the annexation to the
9:33
first Mexican empire now being mostly a part of the Mexican state of Chiapas It seemed that full on independence was never seriously considered and it was always a matter of either joining Mexico or the other Central American states however contrary to some
9:47
other regions, they actually declared their own independence from the Spanish crown in
9:51
1821, which could have paved the way for them to become their own country should they have
9:56
decided to do so. Los Altos was effectively independent from 1838 to 39 and then again from 48 to 49 in
10:04
the 1800s but only for a year each time. It was also a part of the Central American Federation and then of Guatemala which they
10:11
declared independence from in the middle of Guatemala's civil war. Contrary to others on this list, it actually had a flag since it actually achieved independence
10:20
even if for a short period of time. It was a modification of the Central American Union flag with a central seal showing a volcano
10:27
in the background with a Quetzal, a local bird symbolizing liberty in front. Since 1871
10:34
it has also been on the present flag of Guatemala. Finally, Miskito. The Miskito people who speak
10:39
the Miskito language exist in the eastern coast of Central America, facing the Atlantic Ocean
10:45
Today, they exist along the coasts of Honduras and Nicaragua. On paper, it was a part of the
10:50
Viceroyalty of New Granada, but the Spanish never truly held great control of the region
10:54
apparently and at least since the 17th century up to 1894 the Miskito kingdom existed. It's
11:02
important to say that the British called them a kingdom but in reality they were just a group
11:06
of native people without a specific societal structure ruled by the native people themselves
11:11
although having a lot of British influence. Here is their coat of arms, red and white with native
11:15
spears and a tree on top. But this coat of arms was just made by the British. The local military
11:21
leaders of the natives established an alliance with the British via the Providence Island
11:26
Company, joining up in fighting the Spanish together. Local native rule continued and it
11:30
wasn't until 1860 that Britain recognized Nicaragua's claim over the Mosquito Coast
11:36
long after the Spanish were gone, with formal control only being established in 1894. If the
11:42
British hadn't recognized the claims and preferred to maintain its local influence
11:46
perhaps this could have been an additional country in Central America today
11:50
So, those are a few countries that almost existed. From the idealized Polish-Czechoslovak Federation
11:56
to the Greek Republic of Pontus in Turkey or a greater Armenia. Learning about the potential
12:01
creation of a free state of Antwerp to a united Bengal, a great Middle Eastern Union and an
12:07
additional potential country in between Denmark and Germany, sharing heritage with both as well as
12:13
three small Central American regions that could have become independent. If circumstances had
12:18
had been different, any of these could have existed and lasted until today
12:22
Making us think of how current countries result from sometimes the oddest and luckiest combination
12:27
of factors and circumstances, countries that almost didn't exist would also be a good
12:31
topic, looking at states that managed to achieve independence due to some lucky event
12:36
Let me know in the comments if you'd like to see that, along with any other countries that almost existed that you know and which I didn't mention here
12:43
Thanks so much for watching this video, subscribe if you want and I will see you next time for
12:48
more general knowledge
#education
#Hobbies & Leisure