Ryan McCartan as Jay Gatsby

Ryan McCartan as Jay Gatsby Ryan McCartan is taking on the role of a lifetime—Jay Gatsby. And let’s be honest, those are some pretty fancy shoes to fill. (Probably made of the finest leather and polished to perfection.) McCartan, best known for his work in Heathers: The Musical and Liv and Maddie, is stepping into the spotlight as the mysterious millionaire in The Great Gatsby: The Immersive Show. If you've ever dreamed of being whisked away to the roaring twenties, sipping cocktails, and dancing the night away, this show is your golden ticket. (No green light necessary!)